The art and science behind a Carta 409A


A common saying in the valuation industry is that 409A is both an art and a science. At Carta we combine art with science to produce over 200 AICPA compliant, audit-defensible valuation reports every month. This post breaks down the art and science behind a Carta 409A.

The Art: collecting data and selecting methodologies

Companies begin the Carta 409A process by submitting a request form. The form includes structured data like peer public companies, projected financials, and balance sheets.

Companies can connect Carta to QuickBooks or Xero. Connected financials let the data to flow directly into Carta, eliminating the risk of data entry errors.

Once the request is submitted, a Carta analyst will schedule the kick-off call. Analysts review the request form before the call to address any outstanding questions. Any intangibles like projected changes to your business are covered on the call.

The Science: how we use software to inform decisions

Every valuation requires unique inputs and methodologies. These are selected and reviewed by our team of analysts. There are a few steps, however, that can be improved with software.

Determining volatility is one of them. Traditionally, valuation firms will select a list of peer public companies and manually pull their volatility measures. At Carta, our analysts still select the peer public companies, but use a software integration with Capital IQ to pull the volatility measures.

Valuations also require industry specific inputs, which are traditionally pulled manually into the report. Similar to the Capital IQ integration, our analysts use a dashboard that connects directly to IBIS World and pulls the relevant industry inputs.

An important part of the valuation process is generating the option pricing model (OPM) and discount for lack of marketability (DLOM). In the past, these processes were done by hand and took hours to complete. On Carta, we can generate these calculations immediately because we have cap tables and financials saved as structured data.

All formulas are included in the reports. This allows analysts to review and adjust the OPM and DLOM if needed.

Art with Science: tying it together with a final review

The last step in every Carta 409A is the review process. Each report is reviewed by multiple analysts and a valuations manager to approve the report.

Our analysts conduct the entire review process from within a Carta dashboard, letting them communicate and share comments easily.

Once reviewed, the final draft is sent for the company’s approval. Any outstanding questions are answered on a final call before confirming the valuation price.

We hope this provides a better understanding of our valuations process and how software helps our team produce great results.


Related articles


What’s Rule 701 and what’s recently changed?

Learn more about Rule 701, recent updates, and how to stay compliant at your company. Everything from the history of Rule 701 to the most recent changes.

What is a 409A valuation?

Learn everything you need to know about section 409A of the internal revenue code. From what is a 409A valuation to 409A methodologies and process.

Equity 101 – Equity Basics for Founders

Learn the basics of equity, how to distribute equity to early employees, and what a cap table is

eShares, Inc. DBA Carta, Inc. is a transfer agent registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The services and information described in this communication are provided to you “as is” and “as available” without warranties of any kind, expressed, implied or otherwise, including but not limited to all warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, or non-infringement. Neither eShares, Inc. DBA Carta, Inc. nor any of its affiliates will be liable for any damages, including without limitation direct, indirect, special, punitive or consequential damages, caused in any way or arising from the use of the services or reliance upon the information provided in this communication or in connection with any failure of performance, error, omission, interruption, defect, delay in operation or transmission, computer virus or line or system failure. Transfer Agent services for DTC-eligible registered companies provided by Philadelphia Stock Transfer, a Carta affiliate. Carta Securities LLC is a broker-dealer and a member of FINRA and SIPC. Contact: eShares, Inc. DBA Carta, Inc., 195 Page Mill Road, Suite 101, Palo Alto, CA 94306.

© 2018 ESHARES, INC. DBA CARTA, INC.